Pizza restaurants

New York Pizza - Moneta

4.7 144 reviews Closed 13300 Booker T Washington Hwy, Moneta, VA 24121, United States

Discover this place

New York Pizza is a pizza restaurant located at 13300 Booker T Washington Hwy in Moneta, Virginia. The eatery offers a variety of traditional and creative pizza options inspired by classic New York-style slices. The menu features a range of choices including cheese, margherita, veggie, meat lovers, and supreme pizzas, as well as specialty items like the pepperoni and jalapeño calzone and the veggie pizza with sausage. The atmosphere is casual and straightforward, catering to those looking for a familiar and comfortable dining experience focused on quality pizza. The diverse selection of pizzas and calzones highlights the brand’s dedication to delivering authentic, satisfying meals suitable for a variety of tastes. New York Pizza is recognized locally for its consistent approach to classic New York-style pizza that blends simple ingredients with straightforward preparation.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Quiet

Crowd

Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with New York Pizza - Moneta before visiting.

Reviews for New York Pizza - Moneta

4.7

144 reviews

100%

17%

Review highlights

Based on 144 reviews

New York Pizza in Moneta, VA, consistently receives praise for its authentic New York-style pizza, characterized by a flavorful, thin crust and generous toppings. Customers frequently commend the quality and taste, often highlighting the genuine Italian preparation that brings a true New York experience to the area. The restaurant’s menu variety, including popular items beyond pizza like Stromboli and cannolis, adds to its appeal. Reviewers also appreciate the welcoming, family-owned atmosphere, noting attentive and friendly service that enhances the overall dining experience. Reasonable pricing combined with prompt order fulfillment further contributes to strong customer satisfaction. Overall, New York Pizza stands out as a reliable local favorite that successfully captures the essence of classic New York pizzeria tradition while maintaining excellent service and a warm, inviting environment.

ChrisP

Jul 08, 2025

Best pizza in town bar none. Don't waste your time with Dominoes and Papa John's. Great family owned restaurant, real NY style pizza, and awesome cannolis!

Edward Rook

Jun 25, 2025

This pizza will bring you back to the Big Apple in a single bite! Pizza is made by an actual Italian who is sweet and quick with service and holds legitimate claim to the secrets of pizza making. This is the real thing! I have never experienced this outside of New York. If you are a New Yorker or have been to New York and eaten the pizza there, you will be fully satisfied!

gillscreekman

Jun 13, 2025

This evening I placed an order for a Stromboli. The Stromboli was absolutely fantastic! My order was ready for pickup when I arrived and I was greeted with a very nice smile and hello. I would recommend this establishment to anyone. Thanks for a great meal and incredible customer service!!

Amanda Hunt

May 14, 2025

FANTASTIC! Ii had been AT LEAST 10 years or more since I have ate a New York Pizza, and they did not disappoint! The pizza was great! So many topping, great crust, great flavor! Also, GREAT PRICES!

Chris Choi

Apr 25, 2025

Hot, delicious, perfect thin crust pizza, just the way we like it! Ordered five assorted 20" pies for our large group and it was definitely a hit with everyone raving how tasty the pizza is. We devoured it in minutes! Thanks to the staff and owners at New York Pizza for taking caring of us. Cant wait to be back!

Lisa Snyder

Apr 17, 2025

Take Out Only! Pizza is so good!

V B (Vince)

Apr 17, 2025

I typed in New York Pizza with this place in mind, but also knowing I’d be passing by the Vinton Pizza place with basically the same name. The route I had to take home made this place closer to home and ultimately fresher pizza. The pizza was saucier and cheesier than Joes imo. Smaller but tastier than Benny’s, a pepperoni slice was delicious, but crust wasn’t as thick and dense as the Vinton location, but the value was better and the flavor was not off. I’m not a fan of Vinny’s even though I’m a Vinny. I even passed Mama Maria’s in Salem today. I still have this place a chance and felt like I won. I got what I paid for and it wasn’t like I settled. I’ve already told my family of this place. If order here again for sure. Hopefully it sticks around.

Moose Simmons

Mar 31, 2025

We ordered for pickup and it was ready in 20 minutes. The staff was friendly and the pizza was very tasty and reasonably priced. We look forward to trying other menu items.